Review: - Your timing in the beginning from 00:00 - 00:13 was excellent, and on beat, as well as accuratley setting the stage for the extreme AU story you tell in the video. The storyline was original and believable. And you showed the p.o.v. of both Haley and Brooke with seamless editing, and a nice flow. It's extremely tricky to be able to switch pov's midway through a video but you did it in a way that was unconfusing and seemed to go perfectly with the song and the storyline. Your use of song was on point, and you conveyed the varying emotions of Brooke, Lucas, and Haley nicely.I liked how you paralled with Brooke watching L/H together then later with Haley watching L/B together. I really admired how you manipluated the context of certain scenes between the three of them to fit your "fantasy OTH storyline/world" like the hospital scene. My favorite parts were the chorus parts. And then making the story go in the direction of Brooke being killed via the school shooting was just ... brilliance. I loved how you worked the funeral scene in there to accompany "brooke's death". I thought it was the perfect way to neatly wrap up the "triangle", because Brooke's death would mean that Lucas would HAVE to give L/H a shot. And the black/white shot of Brooke watching them at the end was perfectly bittersweet.

Review by Judge: - Wow this was a really creative video. It was sad also. I loved how you showed how Haley wants to be with Lucas but Lucas is with Brooke and even though they are together, Brooke sees how Lucas feels for Haley. So before she died, she wrote a letter to Haley to tell her she can be with Lucas. All the scenes you used definitely showed that and the song you used was perfect to show this. The song also had a sad effect to it also. I loved it.