Review By Judge: Wow, Great AU. That was a really good look at Nathan and Brooke, and you made it work so well. Especially considering that you never showed Haley once. I really liked how you made it that Nathan was dating Brooke and then Brooke moved to Lucas and Then they She broke up with Lucas to be with Nathan. That was really, really awesomely planned out. The song helped the concept run smoothly. Well Done, Again…Great AU!